TOG Review (RCOG Journal)
MRCOG Part 2
Teaching and Research
Giving effective feedback in medical education
Key Statistics
- 4 — Stages, Kolb's learning cycle
- 5 — Named feedback models
- 4 — Stages, competence → performance
Don't-miss facts
-
Feedback loop completes only when the learner acts to change practice — not simply when information is given
-
Kolb’s cycle: concrete experience → reflective observation → abstract conceptualisation → active experimentation (4 stages, enter at any point)
-
Pendleton’s rule (1984): learner states what went well → trainer confirms → learner identifies improvement areas → trainer adds & advises how to improve; best for practical skills
-
PROMPTED: Precise, Relevant, Outcome-based, Measureable, Possible, Time-determined, Encouraging, Descriptive
-
Avoid: unsolicited feedback, old mistakes, personal criticism, public feedback, overload (>2–3 points), feedback in anger, immediate feedback after a serious adverse event
-
ES–trainee meetings every 3–4 months; TO2 multi-source feedback needs ≥10 respondents
-
Trainer–trainee feedback mismatch: poor self-reflection + emotional reactions + weak metacognition
-
Ethical issues: being dishonestly kind; unconscious bias in feedback
Two trainee orientations
Goal-orientated: seeks knowledge/skills, responds well to feedback
Performance-orientated: seeks positive comments/completed WPBAs
Abbreviation Key
- ES — educational supervisor
- TO2 — Team Observation form (multi-source feedback, ≥10 respondents)
- CS — clinical supervisor
- PROMPTED — Precise, Relevant, Outcome-based, Measureable,
- WPBA — workplace-based assessment Possible, Time-determined, Encouraging, Descriptive
- ARCP — Annual Review of Clinical Progress
Source: Qureshi NS. Giving effective feedback in medical education. The Obstetrician & Gynaecologist 2017;19:243–8. doi:10.1111/tog.12391
MRCOG AI is an independent educational tool. It is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or connected to the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists (RCOG).