TOG Review (RCOG Journal)

MRCOG Part 2

Teaching and Research

Litigation in gynaecology

Key Statistics

  • £1.28bn — NHS clinical negligence bill 2011–12 (↑45%)
  • 3 years — Limitation period for a claim
  • 70% — Gynaecology claims successfully defended

Don't-miss facts

  1. Limitation: 3 years from injury/date of knowledge; child → from 18th birthday; no limit if lacking capacity; death → 3 years from death

  2. Four elements of negligence: duty → breach → causal link → harm

  3. Only 1–2% of claims reach court; 70% successfully defended; most settled out of court; most cases are multi-track

  4. Sterilisation: conception <12 months = technique failure; >12 months = recanalisation. McFarlane (healthy child = no upkeep costs) vs Parkinson (disabled child = additional costs)

  5. Hysteroscopic perforation: no electrosurgery → observe; electrosurgery used → laparoscopy to exclude bowel injury

  6. Diathermy tip stays hot after power is switched off; rule out bowel injury after primary trocar insertion

  7. Retained foreign body = SUI → inevitably results in payment of a negligence claim

  8. NHS vicarious liability does not cover coronial enquiry or GMC proceedings — keep defence organisation cover

Case law one-liners

Bolam – responsible body of opinion Bolitho – opinion must be logical Roe – knowledge at time of incident

Ashcroft – burden on claimant, balance of probabilities Hunter v Hanley – departure from routine ≠ negligence

Wilsher – post occupied, “but for” Chester v Afshar – disclose small serious risks

Gillick / Fraser – competence & contraception <16 Janaway – conscientious objection, refer on

Avoiding litigation

Documentation · communication · accurate representation of experience

Discharge instructions · saying sorry (Duty of Candour, Francis) · integrity

Abbreviation Key

  • NHSLA — NHS Litigation Authority
  • NICE — National Institute for Health and Care Excellence
  • MDU — Medical Defence Union
  • IPG — interventional procedure guidance (NICE)
  • MPS — Medical Protection Society
  • SUI — serious untoward incident
  • GMC — General Medical Council
  • IUCD — intrauterine contraceptive device
  • RCOG — Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists
  • CS — caesarean section

Source: Jha S, Rowland S. Litigation in gynaecology. The Obstetrician & Gynaecologist 2014;16:51–57. doi:10.1111/tog.12065

MRCOG AI is an independent educational tool. It is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or connected to the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists (RCOG).

Included with a Pass Package

  • Audio overview of this guideline
  • Practice questions drawn from it
  • AI tutor answers grounded in its text
  • Your own annotations
Start free