TOG Review (RCOG Journal)
MRCOG Part 2
Teaching and Research
Medicolegal update on consent
Key Statistics
- 2015 — Supreme Court ruling (UK)
- 9–10% — Shoulder dystocia risk, diabetic mothers
- 16% — Dystocia predicted by risk factors
Don't-miss facts
-
Standard is now the reasonable patient, not the reasonable doctor — Bolam/Sidaway no longer governs consent
-
Disclose all material risks plus all reasonable alternative or variant treatments — legal and professional duty
-
Materiality = significance to a reasonable person in this patient’s position, or to this particular patient as the doctor should know
-
A patient’s specific question must always be answered (Chester v Afshar) — no size threshold
-
The old ‘<10% need not be disclosed’ Sidaway rule is dead — do not rely on it
-
Shoulder dystocia: 9–10% in diabetic mothers; offer elective caesarean if diabetes or previous dystocia
-
16% of dystocia predicted by risk factors; 84% unpredicted in low-risk labours
-
Document the discussion — PPH and severe perineal tears likewise occur when the only risk is childbirth itself
Old law vs new law
Sidaway/Bolam: doctor-centred, <10% risk non-disclosable Montgomery: patient-centred, all material risks + alternatives
Chester v Afshar: always answer a direct question
Abbreviation Key
- GMC — General Medical Council
- Sidaway — Sidaway v Bethlem
- NICE — National Institute for Health and Care Excellence
- Chester — Chester v Afshar
- Bolam — Bolam v Friern
Source: Cheung E, Goodyear G, Yoong W. Medicolegal update on consent: the Montgomery Ruling. The Obstetrician & Gynaecologist 2016;18:171–2. doi:10.1111/tog.12303
MRCOG AI is an independent educational tool. It is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or connected to the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists (RCOG).