TOG Review (RCOG Journal)
MRCOG Part 2
Subfertility and Reproductive Medicine
The role of frozen-thawed embryo replacement cycles in assisted conception
Key Statistics
- 99% — Rise in UK FER cycles, 2012–17
- >95% — Post-thaw survival, vitrification
- 1–3% — OHSS rate with freeze-all (vs 7% fresh)
Don't-miss facts
-
Vitrification post-thaw survival >95%; superior live-birth rate to slow freezing across RCT, large cohort & meta-analysis
-
Freeze-all cuts OHSS 7% → 1–3% (Cochrane); no live-birth benefit over fresh in general/ovulatory patients, but benefits high responders (PCOS/high antral follicle count)
-
2019 RCT (n=1650): freeze-all 50% vs 40% live birth (RR 1.26) but longer time-to-pregnancy, no cumulative benefit, and 3× pre-eclampsia risk (RR 3.1)
-
FER ↑ risk of large-for-gestational-age (>4500g RR 1.85) and gestational hypertensive disorders/PPH, but ↓ preterm birth, low birthweight, SGA
-
Cancellation: natural cycle FER 8–15% vs medicated 1–2%; endometrium <7 mm linked to falling live-birth rate (>18,000-cycle registry)
-
Blastocyst transfer dating: 2 weeks 5 days gestation at transfer; pregnancy test at 11 days post-transfer = 4 weeks 2 days
-
UK statutory embryo storage limit 10 years (up to 55 years if premature infertility likely); consent of both gamete providers mandatory – Natalie Evans case (2007)
-
Private embryo storage costs approx £200–500/year; NHS funding varies widely, risking discard of viable embryos
Freeze-all: WHO benefits
High responders (≥15 oocytes, PCOS, AFC>15): benefit Low/intermediate responders: no benefit / worse
Abbreviation Key
- FER — frozen–thawed embryo replacement
- RCT — randomised controlled trial
- IVF — in vitro fertilisation
- RR — relative risk
- OHSS — ovarian hyperstimulation syndrome
- CI — confidence interval
- hCG — human chorionic gonadotrophin
- SGA — small for gestational age
- GnRH — gonadotrophin-releasing hormone
- ZP — zona pellucida
- LH — luteinising hormone
- TE — trophectoderm
- HFEA — Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority
- AH — assisted hatching
- PCOS — polycystic ovarian syndrome
- ET — embryo transfer
Source: Noble M, Child T. The role of frozen–thawed embryo replacement cycles in assisted conception. The Obstetrician & Gynaecologist 2020;22:57–68. doi:10.1111/tog.12630
MRCOG AI is an independent educational tool. It is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or connected to the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists (RCOG).