TOG Review (RCOG Journal)
MRCOG Part 2
Subfertility and Reproductive Medicine
The role of tubal patency tests and tubal surgery in the era of assisted reproductive techniques
Key Statistics
- 17% — Lifetime incidence of infertility (1 in 6)
- 53% / 87% — HSG sensitivity / specificity
- 0.28 (0.13–0.59) — FRR, bilateral tubal pathology (HSG)
Don't-miss facts
-
Laparoscopy = conventional "gold standard" but has no evidence base to support that label
-
HSG sensitivity 53%, specificity 87%; bilateral pathology FRR 0.28 (0.13–0.59)
-
Water-soluble HSG contrast preferred over oil-soluble despite oil showing higher live-birth OR (safety/image quality)
-
SSTC: catheterisation success 62–90% but pregnancy rate only ~30%; perforation 2%, ectopic 3%
-
Proximal disease (~15%, usually SIN) → resection/anastomosis; distal disease (~85%, hydrosalpinx) → salpingectomy + IVF (OR 2.14 for ongoing pregnancy)
-
Hydrosalpinx treatment before IVF is standard; no evidence of reduced ovarian reserve after salpingectomy
-
Reversal of sterilisation as successful as IVF but not NHS-funded; best prognosis if age <35 and residual tube >4 cm
-
Ineligible-for-IVF patients should not be offered tubal surgery instead (equally costly, less effective)
Test performance at a glance
HyCoSy: Sens 93.3% / Spec 89.7% HSG: Sens 53% / Spec 87% Fertiloscopy: Sens 86% / Spec 100%
Abbreviation Key
- ART — assisted reproductive technique(s)
- FR — fecundity rate
- IVF — in vitro fertilisation
- OR — odds ratio
- HSG — hysterosalpingogram
- CI — confidence interval
- HyCoSy — hysterosalpingo contrast sonography
- OI — ovulation induction
- SIS — saline infusion sonography
- IUI — intrauterine insemination
- SSTC — selective salpingography and tubal catheterisation
- PID — pelvic inflammatory disease
- THL — transvaginal hydrolaparoscopy
- PCT — primary care trust
- POD — pouch of Douglas
- CCG — clinical commissioning group
- CAT — chlamydia antibody test
- NICE — National Institute for Health and Care Excellence
- MIF — micro-immune-fluorescence
- IFR — individual funding request
- ELISA — enzyme linked immunosorbent assay
- LBR — live birth rate
- SIN — salpingitis isthmica nodosa
- PTO/DTO — proximal/distal tubal obstruction
- FRR — fecundity rate ratio
Source: Suresh YN, Narvekar NN. The role of tubal patency tests and tubal surgery in the era of assisted reproductive techniques. The Obstetrician & Gynaecologist 2014;16:37–45. doi:10.1111/tog.12070
MRCOG AI is an independent educational tool. It is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or connected to the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists (RCOG).