TOG Review (RCOG Journal)
MRCOG Part 2
Teaching and Research
Understanding the Mental Capacity Act 2005
Key Statistics
- 16 yrs — Age from which the Act applies
- 18 yrs — Minimum age: advance decision / LPA donor
- Balance of probabilities — Standard to rebut capacity (s2(4))
Don't-miss facts
-
Capacity presumed from 16 yrs (s1(2)); rebut on the balance of probabilities (s2(4))
-
Unwise decision ≠ incapacity (s1(4)) – capacitous refusal of blood is lawful
-
Partner/husband cannot give proxy consent; family are consulted (s4(7)), not decision-makers
-
Act in best interests (s1(5)/s4); s5 gives legal protection, s6 allows proportionate restraint
-
Valid advance decision beats best interests; life-sustaining refusal must meet s25(6) formalities
-
Basic nursing care (hygiene, warmth, food, pressure care) can never be refused in advance
-
LPA donee cannot refuse life-sustaining treatment unless specified; later LPA overrides earlier advance decision (s25(2)(b))
-
Family–doctor conflict over best interests → consult the Independent Mental Capacity Advocate
Key sections at a glance
s1(2) presumption · s1(4) unwise · s1(5) best interests s2 two-stage test · s3(3) retention · s3(4) consequences
s4(7) consult · s4(9) reasonable belief · s4(10) life-sustaining s5 protection · s6 restraint · s9 LPA · s25(6) formalities
No statutory provision for pregnancy – case by case
Abbreviation Key
- MCA — Mental Capacity Act 2005 Advance
- decision — living will / advance directive / advance refusal
- LPA — Lasting Power of Attorney Re
- C — common law case underpinning the test for capacity
- Donor / Donee — person creating the LPA / attorney appointed to
- Battery — unlawful touching – tort/criminal offence decide for them
- OPG — Office of the Public Guardian
- IMCA — Independent Mental Capacity Advocate
Source: Nicholas N, Nicholas S. Understanding the Mental Capacity Act 2005: a guide for clinicians. The Obstetrician & Gynaecologist 2010;12:29–34. doi:10.1576/toag.12.1.029.27555
MRCOG AI is an independent educational tool. It is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or connected to the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists (RCOG).